A few weeks ago Scout Willis, daughter of Bruce Willis and Demi Moore, took to the streets of NYC in protest of Instagram’s terms of use that do not allow pictures of topless women to be shared on their app. Now this may seem harmless except Scout was topless and recently kicked off the social network for instances of abuse (Harrington). “I am not trying to argue for mandatory toplessness, or even bralessness. What I am arguing for is a woman’s right to choose how she represents her body — and to make that choice based on personal desire and not a fear of how people will react to her or how society will judge her,” Willis wrote (Willis). Many argued that she is just “an attention-seeking, over-privileged, ignorant, white girl” (Powell). But does she have a point?
Source: SMH.com
It was illegal at one time for men to appear bare chested in public, however that changed in 1936 when the ban was lifted and the perception of male nipples slowly changed from obscene to normal. Women made headway in the judicial system as well, when New York’s Supreme Court decriminalized the display of female nipples on public in 1992 (Powell). Technically, women can walk the streets of New York City topless without being arrested, however that has not stopped cops from charging women who have expressed this right. Today, women are focused on equality and closing the perception gap between the male and female breasts by desexualizing the image that female breasts embody.
In the film, “Free The Nipple”, director Lina Esco goes to the streets of New York followed by topless women fighting to change the censorship laws in America. “Everyday the media plays glorified images of violence, yet discourages nudity” (Esco). Activist Liv and With set out to start a movement and change the system through publicity stunts and graffiti installations while armed with First Amendment lawyers. The issues this film is addressing are equal rights for men and women, a more balanced system of censorship, and legal rights for all women to breastfeed in public. With supporters such as Miley Cyrus, Liv Tyler, Rihanna, and Lena Dunham, this movement is sure to get media attention and it has.
The female nipple has always been sexualized and censored in the media. Whether it be for inappropriate usage or advised for sexual content, is it right to give the same freedom to women as men? Do you think that the female nipple should be held at the same standard at the male nipple in the media? Silly question but I tend to think there is a big difference between the two. Not only functionality purposes but societal meaning as well. We may have been socially conditioned or it may be societal taboo, however, the sexual connotation surrounding the female nipple has been present for a long time and I do not see the start of a campaign and the backing of a few celebrities as a resolution to this issue. There are gender differences that need to be acknowledged and the visual discretion within the media should continue.
Free The Nipple. Picture. Retrieved from http://www.ynaija.com/free-the-nipple-campaign-topless-women-stage-protest-against-internet-censorship-viewer-discretion/
“Free the Nipple.” Film. http://freethenipple.com/#
Harrington, Suzanne. “Free the nipple: Time to make going topless as unremarkable for women as it is for men.” Irish Examiner. 16 June 2014. Web. 17 June 2014
Powell, Rose. “Scout Willis continues Free the Nipple campaign.” The Sydney Morning Herald. 3 June 2104. Web. 17 June 2014. Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/lifestyle/celebrity/ls-celebrity-news/scout-willis-continues-free-the-nipple-campaign-20140603-zrvng.html
Scout Willis. Picture. Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/lifestyle/celebrity/ls-celebrity-news/scout-willis-continues-free-the-nipple-campaign-20140603-zrvng.html
Willis, Scout. “I Am Scout Willis And This Is The Only Thing I Have To Say About Walking Topless Down The Streets Of New York Last Week.” XO Jane. 2 June 2014. Web. 17 June 2014. Retrieved from http://www.xojane.com/issues/scout-willis-topless-instagram-protest